| baker1 |
I just picked up some C&H powdered sugar, which I've used for decades
and realized there is cornstarch in it. Will this effect recipes? When
a recipe calls for powdered sugar, does it presuppose there is
cornstarch in it?
Thanks
|
|
|
| Jenn Ridley |
baker1 <rpmspammail@san.rr.com> wrote:
>I just picked up some C&H powdered sugar, which I've used for decades
>and realized there is cornstarch in it. Will this effect recipes? When
>a recipe calls for powdered sugar, does it presuppose there is
>cornstarch in it?
Yes. There's been cornstarch in powdered sugar for *years*, probably
since it became commercially available. (I remember asking my mom
about it 30+ years ago, so it's been that long.) It keeps the sugar
from caking. Modern recipes assume the cornstarch is there.
If you're doing historical baking or confectionary, it *might* affect
(note correct word usage) the end result. If you don't like the
result using purchased powdered sugar, you might try powdering your
own sugar. A friend of mine who does medieval confectionary powders
his own sugar, and says it's a lot of work, but for what he does it's
essential.
jenn
--
Jenn Ridley : jridley@chartermi.net
|
|
|
| Vox Humana |
"Jenn Ridley" <jridley@chartermi.net> wrote in message
news:qbvkn11bavmvvth6vugrnrsn26nhr74efb@4ax.com...
> baker1 <rpmspammail@san.rr.com> wrote:
>
> >I just picked up some C&H powdered sugar, which I've used for decades
> >and realized there is cornstarch in it. Will this effect recipes? When
> >a recipe calls for powdered sugar, does it presuppose there is
> >cornstarch in it?
>
> Yes. There's been cornstarch in powdered sugar for *years*, probably
> since it became commercially available. (I remember asking my mom
> about it 30+ years ago, so it's been that long.) It keeps the sugar
> from caking. Modern recipes assume the cornstarch is there.
>
> If you're doing historical baking or confectionary, it *might* affect
> (note correct word usage) the end result. If you don't like the
> result using purchased powdered sugar, you might try powdering your
> own sugar. A friend of mine who does medieval confectionary powders
> his own sugar, and says it's a lot of work, but for what he does it's
> essential.
Not all powdered sugar has cornstarch in it. That is particularly true in
Europe.
|
|
|
| Melinda Meahan - take out TRASH to send |
Jenn Ridley wrote:
>
> own sugar. A friend of mine who does medieval confectionary powders
> his own sugar, and says it's a lot of work, but for what he does it's
> essential.
Is it really that hard? I haven't bought powdered sugar or brown sugar
for at least a dozen years -- buzz it in the blender to make powdered
sugar, and stir in molasses to make brown sugar.
Or is he not allowed to use a blender?
|
|
|
| jacqui{JB} |
"Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:9_vef.99421$Hs.23075@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
> Not all powdered sugar has cornstarch in it. That is
> particularly true in Europe.
It *is* particularly true in Denmark, where I can't get the damned stuff
without cornstarch (this is a major peeve, the lack of choice of staple
products). I can't determine whether it's the sugar itself which is somehow
more coarse or whether it's the cornstarch (where I'm placing my first bet)
that makes my uncooked frostings (butter, powdered sugar, flavoring) gritty.
But I haven't found a solution to it yet (beyond making a cooked-type
frosting, which I don't really want to do) and it really does irk me.
I wonder if it really is as simple as buying sugar in another country. :P
-j
|
|
|
| Vox Humana |
"jacqui{JB}" <shining_one_whMUNGE@ME.hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:437addfa$0$78280$157c6196@dreader1.cybercity.dk...
> "Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:9_vef.99421$Hs.23075@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
>
> > Not all powdered sugar has cornstarch in it. That is
> > particularly true in Europe.
>
> It *is* particularly true in Denmark, where I can't get the damned stuff
> without cornstarch (this is a major peeve, the lack of choice of staple
> products). I can't determine whether it's the sugar itself which is
somehow
> more coarse or whether it's the cornstarch (where I'm placing my first
bet)
> that makes my uncooked frostings (butter, powdered sugar, flavoring)
gritty.
> But I haven't found a solution to it yet (beyond making a cooked-type
> frosting, which I don't really want to do) and it really does irk me.
My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty. Cornstarch is not gritty in
itself and there is very little included in the sugar. Not all sugar is
ground to the same coarseness. The sugar that I get at Sam's or Costco is
not as fine as that sold at the cake supply store. I also don't think one
can come close to producing very fine, uniform powdered sugar at home in the
blender or food processor. I have tried and it doesn't work well. Perhaps
if you have something akin to a Vitamix blender it works, but not with a
generic home unit.
|
|
|
| jacqui{JB} |
"Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:awHef.99488$Hs.59482@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
> My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty.
You could very well be right, I suppose, although it's not the outcome I was
hoping for. I can see it now -- I'm going to have to start buying powdered
sugar when I travel ... and try to explain that strange white powder in my
carryon or suitcase. *chuckle* Sometimes, life is complicated.
-j
|
|
|
| Vox Humana |
"jacqui{JB}" <shining_one_whMUNGE@ME.hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:437b5f23$0$78288$157c6196@dreader1.cybercity.dk...
> "Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:awHef.99488$Hs.59482@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
>
> > My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty.
>
> You could very well be right, I suppose, although it's not the outcome I
was
> hoping for. I can see it now -- I'm going to have to start buying
powdered
> sugar when I travel ... and try to explain that strange white powder in my
> carryon or suitcase. *chuckle* Sometimes, life is complicated.
In the USA, you can find powdered sugar without cornstarch in "natural" or
"health" food stores.
|
|
|
| Chuck |
On Tue, 15 Nov 2005 19:35:00 -0800, Melinda Meahan - take out TRASH to
send <mmeahan@TRASHsonic.net> wrote:
>Jenn Ridley wrote:
>>
>> own sugar. A friend of mine who does medieval confectionary powders
>> his own sugar, and says it's a lot of work, but for what he does it's
>> essential.
>
>Is it really that hard? I haven't bought powdered sugar or brown sugar
>for at least a dozen years -- buzz it in the blender to make powdered
>sugar, and stir in molasses to make brown sugar.
>
>Or is he not allowed to use a blender?
When out of confectionery sugar,, I grind sugar in my coffee grinder.
(then again.. I didn't need much..)
Chuck
|
|
|
| jake |
jacqui{JB} wrote:
> "Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:awHef.99488$Hs.59482@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
>
>
>>My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty.
>
>
> You could very well be right, I suppose, although it's not the outcome I was
> hoping for. I can see it now -- I'm going to have to start buying powdered
> sugar when I travel ... and try to explain that strange white powder in my
> carryon or suitcase. *chuckle* Sometimes, life is complicated.
>
> -j
>
>
My mother used to grind sugar i a coffee grinder. Don't know if powdered
sugar would become finer using that method, though, because my mother
ground crystals/
|
|
|
| Vox Humana |
"jacqui{JB}" <shining_one_whMUNGE@ME.hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:437b5f23$0$78288$157c6196@dreader1.cybercity.dk...
> "Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:awHef.99488$Hs.59482@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
>
> > My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty.
>
> You could very well be right, I suppose, although it's not the outcome I
was
> hoping for. I can see it now -- I'm going to have to start buying
powdered
> sugar when I travel ... and try to explain that strange white powder in my
> carryon or suitcase. *chuckle* Sometimes, life is complicated.
In the USA, you can find powdered sugar without cornstarch in "natural" or
"health" food stores.
|
|
|
| Jenn Ridley |
baker1 <rpmspammail@san.rr.com> wrote:
>I just picked up some C&H powdered sugar, which I've used for decades
>and realized there is cornstarch in it. Will this effect recipes? When
>a recipe calls for powdered sugar, does it presuppose there is
>cornstarch in it?
Yes. There's been cornstarch in powdered sugar for *years*, probably
since it became commercially available. (I remember asking my mom
about it 30+ years ago, so it's been that long.) It keeps the sugar
from caking. Modern recipes assume the cornstarch is there.
If you're doing historical baking or confectionary, it *might* affect
(note correct word usage) the end result. If you don't like the
result using purchased powdered sugar, you might try powdering your
own sugar. A friend of mine who does medieval confectionary powders
his own sugar, and says it's a lot of work, but for what he does it's
essential.
jenn
--
Jenn Ridley : jridley@chartermi.net
|
|
|
| Melinda Meahan - take out TRASH to send |
Jenn Ridley wrote:
>
> own sugar. A friend of mine who does medieval confectionary powders
> his own sugar, and says it's a lot of work, but for what he does it's
> essential.
Is it really that hard? I haven't bought powdered sugar or brown sugar
for at least a dozen years -- buzz it in the blender to make powdered
sugar, and stir in molasses to make brown sugar.
Or is he not allowed to use a blender?
|
|
|
| jacqui{JB} |
"Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:9_vef.99421$Hs.23075@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
> Not all powdered sugar has cornstarch in it. That is
> particularly true in Europe.
It *is* particularly true in Denmark, where I can't get the damned stuff
without cornstarch (this is a major peeve, the lack of choice of staple
products). I can't determine whether it's the sugar itself which is somehow
more coarse or whether it's the cornstarch (where I'm placing my first bet)
that makes my uncooked frostings (butter, powdered sugar, flavoring) gritty.
But I haven't found a solution to it yet (beyond making a cooked-type
frosting, which I don't really want to do) and it really does irk me.
I wonder if it really is as simple as buying sugar in another country. :P
-j
|
|
|
| Vox Humana |
"jacqui{JB}" <shining_one_whMUNGE@ME.hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:437addfa$0$78280$157c6196@dreader1.cybercity.dk...
> "Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:9_vef.99421$Hs.23075@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
>
> > Not all powdered sugar has cornstarch in it. That is
> > particularly true in Europe.
>
> It *is* particularly true in Denmark, where I can't get the damned stuff
> without cornstarch (this is a major peeve, the lack of choice of staple
> products). I can't determine whether it's the sugar itself which is
somehow
> more coarse or whether it's the cornstarch (where I'm placing my first
bet)
> that makes my uncooked frostings (butter, powdered sugar, flavoring)
gritty.
> But I haven't found a solution to it yet (beyond making a cooked-type
> frosting, which I don't really want to do) and it really does irk me.
My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty. Cornstarch is not gritty in
itself and there is very little included in the sugar. Not all sugar is
ground to the same coarseness. The sugar that I get at Sam's or Costco is
not as fine as that sold at the cake supply store. I also don't think one
can come close to producing very fine, uniform powdered sugar at home in the
blender or food processor. I have tried and it doesn't work well. Perhaps
if you have something akin to a Vitamix blender it works, but not with a
generic home unit.
|
|
|
| jacqui{JB} |
"Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:awHef.99488$Hs.59482@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
> My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty.
You could very well be right, I suppose, although it's not the outcome I was
hoping for. I can see it now -- I'm going to have to start buying powdered
sugar when I travel ... and try to explain that strange white powder in my
carryon or suitcase. *chuckle* Sometimes, life is complicated.
-j
|
|
|
| Chuck |
On Tue, 15 Nov 2005 19:35:00 -0800, Melinda Meahan - take out TRASH to
send <mmeahan@TRASHsonic.net> wrote:
>Jenn Ridley wrote:
>>
>> own sugar. A friend of mine who does medieval confectionary powders
>> his own sugar, and says it's a lot of work, but for what he does it's
>> essential.
>
>Is it really that hard? I haven't bought powdered sugar or brown sugar
>for at least a dozen years -- buzz it in the blender to make powdered
>sugar, and stir in molasses to make brown sugar.
>
>Or is he not allowed to use a blender?
When out of confectionery sugar,, I grind sugar in my coffee grinder.
(then again.. I didn't need much..)
Chuck
|
|
|
| Geoman1 |
"Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
news:awHef.99488$Hs.59482@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
>
> "jacqui{JB}" <shining_one_whMUNGE@ME.hotmail.com> wrote in message
> news:437addfa$0$78280$157c6196@dreader1.cybercity.dk...
>> "Vox Humana" <vhumana@hotmail.com> wrote in message
>> news:9_vef.99421$Hs.23075@tornado.ohiordc.rr.com...
>>
>> > Not all powdered sugar has cornstarch in it. That is
>> > particularly true in Europe.
>>
>> It *is* particularly true in Denmark, where I can't get the damned stuff
>> without cornstarch (this is a major peeve, the lack of choice of staple
>> products). I can't determine whether it's the sugar itself which is
> somehow
>> more coarse or whether it's the cornstarch (where I'm placing my first
> bet)
>> that makes my uncooked frostings (butter, powdered sugar, flavoring)
> gritty.
>> But I haven't found a solution to it yet (beyond making a cooked-type
>> frosting, which I don't really want to do) and it really does irk me.
>
> My bet would be on the sugar making it gritty. Cornstarch is not gritty
> in
> itself and there is very little included in the sugar. Not all sugar is
> ground to the same coarseness. The sugar that I get at Sam's or Costco is
> not as fine as that sold at the cake supply store. I also don't think one
> can come close to producing very fine, uniform powdered sugar at home in
> the
> blender or food processor. I have tried and it doesn't work well.
> Perhaps
> if you have something akin to a Vitamix blender it works, but not with a
> generic home unit.
Just stopped in for a brief moment and read your post.
I heard and just tried making fine sugar in my Vita Mix. The sugar comes out
very very fine but still not that of cakes. The problem I had is to get the
sugar to travel into the center and recirculate you have to do at least four
cups at a time. It did a great job but not for 2 cups or less, at those
amounts the sugar begins to heat and smell like cotton candy :-)
Rich
>
>
|
|
|
| Dave Bell |
Newsgroups: rec.food.baking
X-Trace: newssvr21.news.prodigy.com 1132798518 ST000 69.237.34.157 (Wed, 23 Nov 2005 21:15:18 EST)
User-Agent: Mozilla Thunderbird 1.0 (Windows/20041206)
X-Accept-Language: en-us, en
MIME-Version: 1.0
In-Reply-To: <sc2dnREgbNiehBjeRVn-pw@adelphia.com>
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1; format=flowed
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
X-Complaints-To: abuse@prodigy.net
NNTP-Posting-Date: Wed, 23 Nov 2005 21:15:18 EST
X-UserInfo1: FKPO@MONQRVYBPXX[@CBNWX@RJ_XPDLMN@GZ_GYO^BTBTSUBYF
WEAE[YJLYPIWKHTFCMZKVMB^[Z^DOBRVVMOSPFHNSYXVDIE@X\
BUC@GTSX@DL^GKFFHQCCE\G[JJBMYDYIJCZM@AY]GNGPJD]YNN
W\GSX^GSCKHA[]@CCB\[@LATPD\L@J\\PF]VR[QPJN
Xref: spool6-east.superfeed.net rec.food.baking:67721
Geoman1 wrote:
> I heard and just tried making fine sugar in my Vita Mix. The sugar comes out
> very very fine but still not that of cakes. The problem I had is to get the
> sugar to travel into the center and recirculate you have to do at least four
> cups at a time. It did a great job but not for 2 cups or less, at those
> amounts the sugar begins to heat and smell like cotton candy :-)
>
> Rich
Vitamix is a great blender, but I agree, it's too big for this kind of
job. I use a little whirly-blade coffee mill my wife keeps for grinding
herbs and flax seed. (I use a burr grinder for coffee.) It takes about a
cup at atime, and in 30-60 seconds, reduces granulated sugar to a very
fine powder.
Dave
|
|
|
|
